Advisen FPN

Advisen Front Page News - Wednesday, July 21, 2021

   
Rapid rise in deadly weapons events sparks interest in specialized cover

Advisen

Rapid rise in deadly weapons events sparks interest in specialized cover

By Erin Ayers, Advisen

Demand for dedicated coverage for deadly weapons or active assailant events has skyrocketed in recent months, as mass shootings pick up pace and insurers look to exclude the unpredictable risk from traditional lines.

Specialists in the area of “active shooter” insurance say the market has been developing steadily in recent years, with capacity and buyer interest both rising.

“Because of the increased levels of violence, there is greater demand. We’ve never been busier,” said Chris Parker, head of terrorism and deadly weapons protection at Beazley. The insurer has been offering deadly weapons coverage for several years, he told Advisen, and has found pre-event risk mitigation and crisis response to be the most valuable resources for buyers. It doesn’t replace general liability coverage, but complements it.

“We’re seeing a 100% uptick from this time last year,” said Paul Marshall, managing director of McGowan Program Administrators’ crisis risk/active shooter/workplace violence program. Agents are requesting the cover on behalf of clients and McGowan’s quote-to-bind ratio has jumped to 35%, he said.

“It’s just different this year – it’s the buyers that are driving,” he told Advisen. Agents and brokers need to pay close attention on renewals of general liability policies being renewed with weapons exclusions, particularly for restaurants, casinos, bars, hotels, and grocery store chains.

According to wholesale broker Amwins, the exclusions or sublimits are leading businesses to find new ways to transfer the risk or avoid high retentions.

"Many carriers are excluding or sub-limiting this coverage at renewal, and agents are struggling to find a replacement," said Mark Bernacki, president of Amwins Special Risk Underwriters and Amwins' alternative risk practice leader. The firm recently launched a policy aimed at small and middle-market businesses combining deadly weapons protection and sexual molestation liability coverage.

Bernacki added, "It became clear there was a market gap and need for a coverage solution for these unexpected expenses."

Gun violence continues to increase in the U.S. -- 2020 marked the deadliest year on record, with 611 mass shootings (defined as incidents involving four or more people) 2021 appears to be on a similar trajectory, having already seen 374 mass shooting events, according to the Gun Violence Archive.

The heightened activity has many property/casualty insurers alarmed at the rising costs associated with violent events. Historically, courts have declined to attach liability to businesses due to the unforeseeable nature of these tragedies, but with events occurring with shocking regularity, the tide might be changing. The 2017 shooting at Las Vegas’ Mandalay Bay resort resulted in an $800 million settlement, much of it covered by insurance, and experts suggest it marks a “turning point” for liability.

Despite the common term “active shooter,” most coverages in the market respond to attacks involving most deadly weapons in public spaces and workplaces. The specialized policy fills a coverage gap, and experts say taking care of victims’ physical and mental needs quickly helps avert potential litigation in the future.

“We’re not waiting on the lawsuits – claims professionals are on the ground, day of the event,” said Marshall. “It’s answering the question, who will help the victims. For an insured to know that the bills are going to be paid and they don’t have to rely on a GoFundMe makes a huge difference.”

Parker said the cover offers essential crisis response services that businesses may not have access to otherwise, as well as claims teams that understand the risk.

“Apart from ringing 911, what do you do to respond to this tragedy?” Parker said. “That’s what a lot of clients have struggled with, the crisis response. You’ve got to treat those victims the way you want to be treated yourself.”

He added, “That’s what the attraction is – they’ve got certainty of coverage and the help of a crisis responder.”

Providing first-dollar medical expenses, counseling resources, death benefits, liability protection, and business interruption is the standard for most deadly weapons policies. One option in the market even provides for property restoration, in the event that tragic memories and emotional distress make the site of an event too painful to continue using.

Even before an event, however, the emphasis for deadly weapons coverage is on prevention. The steps a business could have taken before an active assailant event come into play when considering liability, as seen in a lawsuit over the 2018 deadly rampage in the Capital Gazette’s newsroom in Baltimore. Plaintiffs have argued the newspaper had full knowledge of the danger of shooter Jarrod Ramos.

The prevention services help insureds identify risk factors, especially in workplaces, that may lead to an event. Awareness “of the danger signs of someone on the path to violence” is key, according to Parker, and the pre-loss mitigation guidance helps insureds navigate difficult terrain.

When deadly weapons cover first launched, it tended to be aimed at schools, but it has expanded to businesses in all industries, as well as events, music festivals, Pride parades, and concerts.

Underwriters examine an applicant’s geography, daily foot traffic, number of employees, and employee practices, said Marshall. While geography comes into play for litigation potential, gun laws in any given state don’t appear to correlate to more or fewer incidents, he noted.

“If we can underwrite it successfully, we try and do so,” Parker said, adding, “It’s just raising awareness that this risk is out there, it’s getting worse and we need to protect against it.”

Editor Erin Ayers can be reached at [email protected]

Liberty Mutual
Advisen